Alan Shearer Claims Nick Woltemade Hampers Newcastle’s Press

Nick Woltemade’s arrival at Newcastle United has stirred debate, with club legend Alan Shearer openly discussing the striker’s impact on the Magpies’ pressing game and overall team dynamics. The Magpies have entered the 2025/26 Premier League season on shaky ground, sitting 14th in the table after just three wins in their first 11 matches, only narrowly above the relegation zone.

Nick Woltemade’s Role Raises Concerns for Newcastle

Nick Woltemade joined Newcastle United from Stuttgart during the summer, touted as a promising addition to reinforce their attacking options. However, Alan Shearer believes the German forward has become a “problem” for Newcastle, specifically citing Woltemade’s limitations in pressing and pace.

Shearer explained, “Eddie Howe’s Newcastle sides have always thrived on energy, high pressing, and relentless running in behind defenders. Players like Alexander Isak and Callum Wilson embodied Howe’s philosophy. Woltemade, despite his technical ability, just doesn’t fit that mold—he’s not quick enough, doesn’t press effectively, and rarely threatens with runs in behind. It’s shifted the team’s balance, especially when the pressing game is essential to Newcastle’s identity.”

Newcastle’s Dip in Form and Howe’s Challenge

The current campaign stands in stark contrast to last season’s historic achievements. Newcastle ended their 70-year trophy drought by winning the Carabao Cup and finishing fifth for a Champions League spot. This term, however, results have deteriorated. Their latest defeat—a 3-1 loss to Brentford—has intensified scrutiny on manager Eddie Howe.

Howe himself has voiced concerns about the squad’s mentality and energy. After the loss at West Ham, Howe remarked, “The dynamism wasn’t there. The physicality and the energy were missing. We didn’t look like the Newcastle team of previous seasons.”

Shearer and Krul Defend Howe Amid Sack Rumors

Amid mounting speculation regarding Howe’s future, Shearer argued that the manager retains significant goodwill thanks to his transformative impact, including the club’s recent silverware. “Any manager is under pressure for results, but Howe has earned respect and patience,” said Shearer.

Former Newcastle goalkeeper Tim Krul echoed this sentiment, telling Sky Sports, “Eddie has changed the club and city’s expectations. Yes, criticism is fair given the poor away form, but fans would have gladly chosen this scenario—winning a trophy and challenging for Champions League spots—just a few years ago.”

Nick Woltemade’s Stats: Productive But Unbalanced?

Despite Shearer’s criticism, Woltemade’s numbers offer a different perspective. He has scored seven goals in 17 appearances across all competitions since arriving from Stuttgart, netting four times in eight Premier League outings. Statistically, Woltemade has contributed positively but questions linger about his fit within Howe’s tactical system.

Woltemade looks to add to his tally when Newcastle face Manchester City at home on November 22—a crucial fixture as the Magpies aim to recover from their poor start.

Can Howe Adapt and Get the Magpies Back on Track?

With pressure mounting, Newcastle’s season hinges on Howe’s ability to adapt his tactics and possibly reintegrate pressing intensity. The situation also raises broader questions about summer recruitment and whether new arrivals align with the manager’s preferred playing style.

For more news, visit for more news.

Opinion: Howe Deserves More Time But Recruitment Must Improve

Newcastle’s pressing issues are emblematic of a wider recruitment challenge. While Nick Woltemade has contributed goals, his style appears at odds with Howe’s philosophy. Sacking Howe now would be premature given his recent achievements, but the club must address squad balance quickly to avoid a season of disappointment.