Chelsea Women’s Player Ratings: Macario Shines in 1-1 Draw

Chelsea women’s player ratings were the talk of Friday night as the Blues saw their perfect Women’s Super League start halted by Manchester United in a tense 1-1 draw. Catarina Macario’s creative spark drove Chelsea’s attack but, ultimately, both sides had to settle for a share of the spoils.

Chelsea Women’s Player Ratings: Mixed Night for the Blues

Chelsea women’s player ratings reflect a night of highs and lows for Sonia Bompastor’s squad. The Blues entered the match with an immaculate record, having won each of their opening four WSL fixtures. Facing a spirited Manchester United at Leigh Sports Village, Chelsea saw their momentum checked but showed flashes of brilliance—particularly from Macario.

Fast Start and Macario’s Magic

Chelsea began brightly, with their midfield carving up United’s defenses. A slick team move saw Wieke Kaptein open the scoring inside ten minutes. The highlight was Catarina Macario’s audacious backheel, an assist that underlined her technical flair and vision. Macario’s influence was clear in both her passing and off-the-ball movement, earning her top marks in the Chelsea women’s player ratings.

United Respond with Sandberg’s Stunner

Manchester United refused to be overawed. After conceding early, they grew into the game, equalizing through Anna Sandberg’s superb finish on 20 minutes—her first goal for the club. Chelsea’s usually robust midfield looked vulnerable at times, allowing United to dominate possession and create several chances. Phallon Tullis-Joyce’s reflex saves kept Chelsea from falling behind, while Melvine Malard missed a golden opportunity to put United ahead in the second half.

Key Performances in Chelsea Women’s Player Ratings

Kaptein was energetic, dynamic, and unlucky not to add a second after being denied by Tullis-Joyce. Macario, however, was the creative heartbeat, constantly probing United’s backline and providing Chelsea with much-needed impetus. Defensive stalwart Niamh Charles put in a solid shift under pressure, while Fran Kirby showed flashes of her best but struggled to impose herself fully.

Squad Depth Tested

Chelsea’s depth was challenged as United pressed relentlessly. Substitutions brought fresh legs but didn’t tip the balance. Lauren James and Johanna Rytting Kaneryd injected pace, but the final ball often eluded the forwards.

Honest Player Ratings

– Ann-Katrin Berger (GK): 6 – Little to do, beaten well for United’s goal.
– Niamh Charles: 7 – Defensively sound, good overlapping runs.
– Millie Bright: 7 – Commanding, but occasionally exposed.
– Guro Reiten: 6 – Quiet night by her standards.
– Catarina Macario: 8 – The standout, her creativity pivotal.
– Wieke Kaptein: 7 – Well-taken goal, tireless engine.
– Fran Kirby: 6 – Moments of quality but not her most influential.
– Lauren James: 6 – Impactful cameo, lacked end product.

What the Result Means for Chelsea Women

Chelsea women’s player ratings show a team that, despite not firing on all cylinders, remains tough to beat. Manchester United’s improvement against a top side signals a more competitive WSL campaign. For Chelsea, dropping points is a wake-up call but also a chance to regroup and refine their attacking rhythm.

Opinion: Chelsea’s Resilience Will Define Their Title Push

Chelsea may have lost their perfect start, but their ability to battle through adversity and earn hard-fought results is a strength. Macario’s performance reaffirms her status as a key figure going forward; if the Blues can blend her creativity with greater attacking consistency, their title defense remains on solid ground. United’s resilience, meanwhile, suggests they’ll be a thorn in the side of every contender.

For more news on Chelsea Women and the latest from the WSL, visit for more news.