Gary Neville Slams Man Utd Player After Everton Defeat

Gary Neville Criticizes Manchester United After Shock Everton Loss

Manchester United suffered a frustrating 1-0 home defeat to 10-man Everton, drawing strong criticism from club legend Gary Neville. The outspoken pundit singled out Luke Shaw, describing the defender’s contribution as a “waste of time” and lambasting his lack of urgency during the crucial Premier League fixture.

Luke Shaw’s Performance Questioned as United Struggles Continue

Luke Shaw’s return to fitness this season was expected to bolster United’s defense, especially under Ruben Amorim’s tactical setup. Deployed as a left center-back in a three-man backline, Shaw has featured consistently for United. However, Neville was unimpressed with Shaw’s display against Everton, highlighting his slow movement and lack of drive when United needed to break down a determined opponent reduced to ten men.

Speaking during his analysis on Sky Sports, Neville did not mince words: “You have to play with urgency against ten men. Shaw starts to move forward, but he’s just ambling. You can’t do that—he should be running forward every time. What Shaw is doing there, you’re not conning anybody. It’s a waste of time.”

Fan Frustration as United’s Unbeaten Run Ends

The mood inside Old Trafford soured further as the Red Devils’ five-match unbeaten Premier League streak came to an abrupt end. The home crowd’s boos at the final whistle reflected growing concerns over Manchester United’s ability to convert dominance into points, especially against sides like Everton who played a significant portion of the match a man down.

Amorim’s Tactical Challenge and Defensive Weaknesses

Manager Ruben Amorim’s faith in Shaw has yet to yield consistent defensive solidity. The team struggled to adjust after Everton’s Seamus Coleman was forced off with an injury, and despite having the numerical advantage, United lacked the creativity and intensity needed to capitalize. Shaw’s hesitant forward runs and conservative play contributed to United’s lack of penetration, which was a key factor in the defeat.

Everton’s Grit and Moyes’ Historic Victory at Old Trafford

While United faltered, Everton showed remarkable resilience. Despite losing their captain early and going down to 10 men, the Toffees reorganized effectively. Former United manager David Moyes finally secured his first win at Old Trafford as a visiting boss after 18 attempts—a major milestone. Moyes praised his players’ mental strength, noting their ability to hold their shape and exploit United’s weaknesses even under intense pressure.

Social Media Reactions: Former Players Weigh In

Neville’s outspoken criticism of Shaw drew mixed reactions online. Ex-Everton winger Yannick Bolasie took aim at Neville’s punditry on social media, suggesting that excessive analysis and laughter from the studio were unnecessary. Bolasie wrote, “Great player but the tactics give it a rest laaaad,” highlighting the divide between former professionals and current pundits.

What’s Next for Manchester United and Everton?

With the loss, Manchester United faces mounting questions about their defensive strategy and squad mentality. The Red Devils will look to regroup as they prepare to travel to Crystal Palace, hoping to rediscover the spark that carried them through their recent unbeaten run. Everton, buoyed by their resilient display and historic win, now turn their attention to a tough home fixture against Newcastle United.

For Manchester United fans and neutrals alike, the focus will be on whether Amorim can inspire his side to bounce back and whether Luke Shaw can answer his critics by showing greater urgency and leadership on the pitch. For more news on Premier League drama, visit our homepage at for more news.

Opinion: Accountability Needed for United’s Defensive Leaders

Manchester United’s defeat to Everton was not just about missed opportunities but also about leadership and accountability—qualities Gary Neville was right to demand. Shaw’s experience should translate into drive and commitment, especially during adversity. United cannot afford lapses in intensity if they are to compete at the highest level. The coming weeks will be a true test of character for both the player and the team.