Liverpool Disallowed Goal Sparks VAR Controversy in Man City Defeat

Liverpool disallowed goal controversy dominated discussions following their 3-0 Premier League defeat to Manchester City, as the Reds officially lodged a complaint with the Professional Game Match Officials Ltd (PGMOL) and refereeing chief Howard Webb. The club raised significant concerns over the decision that saw Virgil van Dijk’s crucial first-half header ruled out due to an offside call on Andy Robertson.

Liverpool Disallowed Goal: The Key Incident

The pivotal moment arrived in the 38th minute at the Etihad Stadium. Liverpool, trailing 1-0, seemed to have drawn level when Virgil van Dijk powered home a corner. However, the celebration was cut short as referee Chris Kavanagh, supported by VAR official Michael Oliver, judged that Andy Robertson was in an offside position and interfering with play, having ducked in front of Manchester City goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma. The Premier League later clarified: “The referee’s call of offside and no goal to Liverpool was checked and confirmed by VAR – with Robertson in an offside position and deemed to be making an obvious action directly in front of the goalkeeper.”

Liverpool’s Formal Complaint to PGMOL

Unsatisfied with this explanation, Liverpool submitted an official complaint to PGMOL and Howard Webb. The Merseyside club expressed “serious concerns” about the process and the subjectivity of the decision, arguing that Robertson did not impact Donnarumma’s vision. Liverpool contends that the usual checks and balances associated with the VAR process were not properly followed, suggesting that a different outcome could have been reached had procedures been observed correctly.

Manager Slot Voices Frustration Over Disallowed Goal

Manager Arne Slot was candid in his post-match comments, telling Sky Sports, “It’s obvious and clear that the wrong decision has been made, at least in my opinion. Robertson didn’t interfere at all with what the goalkeeper could do.” Slot referenced a similar incident given in favor of Manchester City in a previous match, questioning the consistency of officiating and VAR communication. He also emphasized that the disallowed goal could have shifted the match’s momentum: “That could have influenced the game in a positive way for us because in the first half we were so poor… It has been an influential decision.”

Van Dijk’s Measured Response

Virgil van Dijk, whose header was chalked off, opted for restraint when questioned about the incident. “The officials are deciding the key decisions and we have to deal with it on the pitch. There is no point discussing this from my point of view,” he remarked. Van Dijk emphasized focusing on the result, admitting the 3-0 loss was a significant blow and declining to be drawn into a wider debate.

Liverpool Disallowed Goal Adds to Crisis Talk

The defeat at the hands of Manchester City compounded Liverpool’s struggles, marking their fifth league loss of the season and leaving them eight points adrift of leaders Arsenal. Former Manchester United captain and TV pundit Roy Keane declared, “Liverpool are in crisis,” criticizing the team’s perceived lack of strength and cohesion despite substantial summer investment.

What’s Next for Liverpool?

With the international break now underway, Arne Slot and his squad have time to regroup and assess their situation. Liverpool’s next fixtures see them face Nottingham Forest in the Premier League, followed by a crucial Champions League encounter against PSV. The coming matches will be critical as the Reds attempt to get their campaign back on track.

Opinion: VAR Must Deliver Consistency

The Liverpool disallowed goal incident underlines persistent questions about the consistency and transparency of VAR in English football. While technology is intended to minimize clear errors, the subjective interpretation of interference and offside remains a grey area, often leading to frustration for players, managers, and fans alike. To ensure trust in the system, clearer communication and uniform application of the rules are essential. As Liverpool reflect on a costly decision, the Premier League must strive for improvements that reinforce the integrity of the game.

For more insights and the latest updates from the football world, visit our homepage for more news.