Man Utd Player Ratings vs Everton: Woeful Display Against 10 Men

Manchester United player ratings vs Everton revealed a night to forget at Old Trafford, as the Red Devils slumped to a 1-0 defeat against a ten-man Everton side. Despite a numerical advantage for almost 80 minutes, United were lackluster, uninspired, and deservedly left the pitch to a chorus of boos from their home supporters.

Manchester United Player Ratings vs Everton: Full Match Analysis

The fixture presented a golden opportunity for Manchester United to climb up the Premier League table following promising results earlier in the autumn. However, Ruben Amorim’s side squandered their chance in front of frustrated fans, leaving many questions about their mentality and approach.

Early Drama: Everton Reduced to Ten, but United Falter

Everton started brightly, forcing United onto the back foot in the opening exchanges. The match turned on its head in the 13th minute, when Idrissa Gueye was shown a red card after a bizarre altercation with his own teammate, Michael Keane. Reminiscent of infamous past incidents like that of Kieron Dyer and Lee Bowyer, Gueye’s dismissal should have paved the way for United dominance.

Yet, instead of capitalizing, United looked toothless. Everton regrouped and, against the odds, took the lead in spectacular fashion. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall unleashed a thunderous strike from distance, beating both Bruno Fernandes and Leny Yoro before finding the top corner.

Red Devils Fail to Break Down Stubborn Everton

With Everton content to sit deep and protect their lead, United monopolized possession but struggled to create meaningful chances. Patrick Dorgu and Amad Diallo both squandered first-half opportunities, while Bruno Fernandes saw a dangerous shot tipped over by Jordan Pickford. Fernandes, usually the team’s creative linchpin, endured a nightmare performance—his passing was sloppy, his positioning suspect, and he wasted a golden chance in the second half by firing over.

Ruben Amorim sought to inject life into his side with a raft of substitutions. Mason Mount’s introduction brought some much-needed urgency and nearly resulted in an equalizer. However, the likes of Kobbie Mainoo and Diogo Dalot also failed to make a decisive impact. Joshua Zirkzee, given a rare start up front, was anonymous for much of the contest and only came alive in the closing stages, twice denied by Pickford.

Manchester United Player Ratings vs Everton: Individual Assessments

Goalkeeper & Defence

• Senne Lammens (5/10): Shouldered some blame for Dewsbury-Hall’s strike but was largely untested otherwise.
• Matthijs de Ligt (4/10): Passive and overly cautious, failed to impose himself despite United’s man advantage.
• Leny Yoro (4/10): Needed to do more to prevent the goal; improved marginally in the second half.
• Luke Shaw (4/10): Struggled against Iliman Ndiaye and contributed little going forward.

Midfield

• Noussair Mazraoui (4/10): Minimal impact from right wing-back, replaced at halftime.
• Casemiro (4/10): Failed to control midfield or disrupt Everton’s rhythm; substituted after a booking.
• Bruno Fernandes (3/10): One of his worst United displays—ineffective, wasteful, and failed to inspire.
• Patrick Dorgu (4/10): Wasted United’s best chance with a poor finish and offered little else.

Attack

• Bryan Mbeumo (6/10): Showed determination and energy but lacked composure in front of goal.
• Joshua Zirkzee (4/10): Missed the opportunity to impress in Sesko’s absence, largely anonymous.
• Amad Diallo (6/10): Flashes of skill but isolated for long stretches, improved later on.

Substitutes & Manager

• Mason Mount (6/10): Added urgency and nearly grabbed an equalizer off the bench.
• Kobbie Mainoo (5/10): Failed to make a significant impact in midfield.
• Diogo Dalot (5/10): Provided some balance but rarely threatened.
• Ruben Amorim (4/10): Tactical decisions backfired; his team’s lack of belief and failure to beat 10 men raise serious concerns.

Everton’s Resilience and United’s Stagnation

Everton’s response to going down to ten men was nothing short of heroic. The Toffees defended valiantly, closed down space, and maintained discipline, while United grew increasingly desperate. The result leaves Manchester United languishing in 10th place, missing a crucial chance to move up the table after a promising run earlier in the season.

What’s Next for Manchester United?

This result is a significant setback for United’s ambitions. All the progress from October and early November now seems undone, and the pressure mounts on Ruben Amorim to find answers quickly. With challenging fixtures ahead, the Red Devils must rediscover their fight and creativity to stay in contention for European places.

For more updates and the latest analysis, visit for more news.

Opinion: Manchester United Must Show Character After Embarrassment

United’s inability to put away a struggling Everton side, especially after gaining a numerical advantage, speaks volumes about their current lack of confidence and tactical cohesion. Bruno Fernandes’ poor form is worrying, and Zirkzee missed his chance to stake a claim for a starting role. If United are to rescue their season, senior players need to step up, and Amorim must deliver solutions—quickly.