Man Utd Transfer Policy Under Fire After Carreras Exit

Manchester United transfer policy has come under intense scrutiny following the recent criticism from former club scout Piotr Sadowski over the sale of Alvaro Carreras. Sadowski has openly questioned the wisdom behind United’s decision to let go of Carreras, a player he regards as “truly top-class,” and suggests the move could haunt the Red Devils for years to come.

Manchester United Transfer Policy Faces Criticism

The Manchester United transfer policy, especially regarding youth development, is facing renewed debate after the emergence of Alvaro Carreras as a rising star in European football. Carreras, a Spanish left-back who joined United at just 16 in 2020, was allowed to leave Old Trafford for Benfica in 2024 for a relatively modest fee. In a twist that has highlighted United’s questionable handling of young talent, Carreras was signed by Real Madrid just a year later for €50 million (£43m), underlining his rapid development and substantial market value.

Sadowski Slams Sale of ‘Top-Class’ Carreras

Former Manchester United scout Piotr Sadowski did not mince words when discussing the club’s transfer decisions in a recent interview with Przeglad Sportowy. “Alvaro Carreras was a very hard-working and ambitious player who quickly adapted to life in Manchester,” Sadowski recalled. “He was loaned to Preston, impressed with his performances, yet United opted to sell him to Benfica for a small sum. Now, he’s moved to Real Madrid, and it’s clear—he’s one of the best young left-backs in the world. Selling him was a huge mistake.”

Sadowski emphasized United’s historical strength in developing youth talent, suggesting the club now lacks the courage to truly invest in their academy players. “Something is missing here, and I think that something is United’s willingness to back young players, instead of looking for immediate solutions in the transfer market.”

Youth Development vs. Short-Term Solutions

The Carreras transfer has reignited concerns over United’s preference for “ready-made players” under current coach Ruben Amorim. Despite the Red Devils’ proud tradition of promoting academy prospects, several homegrown talents have left in recent years, raising fears about the continuity of that legacy.

Sadowski pointed out that the club’s current recruitment strategy, typified by recent signings like Patrick Dorgu, Benjamin Sesko, Matheus Cunha, and Bryan Mbeumo, prioritizes instant impact over long-term development. “Amorim was supposed to rejuvenate the squad with youth, but under pressure for results, he’s opted for established names instead,” Sadowski explained. “With United’s budget, you could find several young players of Dorgu’s level for the price of one, but the club seems reluctant to take that risk now.”

Kobbie Mainoo: The Next Academy Star to Leave?

United’s shifting approach has also cast doubt on the future of current academy star Kobbie Mainoo, who is reportedly out of favor and linked with a move away from Old Trafford. Sadowski’s comments suggest a worrying pattern: United’s reluctance to integrate young talent is pushing promising players to seek opportunities elsewhere, much to the club’s potential detriment.

Amorim’s Run and What Lies Ahead

Despite the criticism, Ruben Amorim has managed to steady the ship at Manchester United with a five-match unbeaten run heading into the international break. The Red Devils will be looking to maintain their momentum when they return to Premier League action at home against Everton on November 24. However, questions about the Manchester United transfer policy and the club’s long-term vision remain front and center for fans and pundits alike.

Opinion: United Must Re-Evaluate Their Transfer Policy

The sale of Alvaro Carreras is a stark reminder that Manchester United’s transfer policy needs urgent reassessment. While short-term results matter, sacrificing the development of top-class young talent contradicts the very foundation of United’s identity. If the club truly wants to restore its legacy, a renewed commitment to nurturing and trusting academy graduates is essential.

For more news and updates on football’s hottest topics, visit for more news.