Man Utd Weigh Up Scott McTominay Return Amid Napoli Success

Scott McTominay transfer talk is heating up as Manchester United reportedly consider bringing the Scotland international back to Old Trafford after his impressive run at Napoli. The midfielder’s journey from United to Serie A has sparked debate over whether the Red Devils made a costly error in letting him go.

Scott McTominay Transfer: From Old Trafford to Napoli Stardom

Scott McTominay transfer news took center stage in 2024 when the midfielder left Manchester United for Napoli in a £26 million move. Previously seen as a squad player at Old Trafford, McTominay has blossomed in Italy, becoming a fan favorite and helping Napoli secure the Serie A title. His 13 goals across all competitions last season, coupled with MVP honors, cemented his reputation as a top-tier midfielder. Despite his success, rumors suggest both McTominay and his partner Cam Reading may be unsettled in their second year in Naples.

Interest Builds: Manchester United, Barcelona, and Premier League Rivals

The latest Scott McTominay transfer speculation has attracted attention from multiple European giants. Manchester United are reportedly eager to correct their previous decision, recognizing McTominay’s value as a home-grown, versatile player. Newcastle United and Tottenham Hotspur are also monitoring the situation, while Barcelona have shown interest in adding McTominay to their midfield options.

According to sources close to the negotiations, “There is concrete interest in Scott McTominay. Manchester United would have him back, and keep an eye on Newcastle and Tottenham. Barcelona also view him as someone who could be a good fit for their midfield.”

Should Manchester United Bring McTominay Back?

McTominay’s departure raised eyebrows among United faithful and former staff alike. Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, who gave McTominay 115 appearances during his tenure as manager, expressed regret over the sale, emphasizing the importance of local talent and McTominay’s leadership qualities. Solskjaer praised McTominay’s physicality, mental strength, and ability to rise to big occasions, recalling games where his tactical adjustments made a significant impact.

However, not everyone at Old Trafford shares this sentiment. Legendary former captain Roy Keane cautioned against re-signing former players, arguing that a return may not provide the transformative effect United need. “Good luck to the lad, but I wasn’t hanging my hat on him every week. If he’s classed as a squad player and you get £30m, it’s not a bad deal,” Keane remarked.

Scott McTominay Contract and Napoli Role

Since joining Napoli, McTominay has added four more goals to his tally in just 14 appearances this season, competing in both Serie A and the Champions League. His current contract with Napoli runs until 2028, and with no clear indication that the Italian club is open to offers, prying McTominay away looks set to be a costly endeavor—estimated at £44 million.

The presence of Rasmus Hojlund, another ex-United player, and former Manchester City star Kevin De Bruyne at Napoli has contributed to a rejuvenated squad, with McTominay playing a key role in their midfield dominance.

International Aspirations and Future Prospects

On the international stage, McTominay remains a central figure for Scotland as they chase automatic qualification for the 2026 World Cup in their upcoming matches against Greece and Denmark. His continued performances at the highest level make him an attractive proposition for clubs seeking experience, leadership, and physical presence in midfield.

Opinion: Is a Manchester United Return the Right Move for McTominay?

While Scott McTominay’s transfer back to Manchester United would be a statement of intent, it also carries risks. His growth at Napoli demonstrates that sometimes a change of environment is essential for unlocking a player’s potential. United must carefully weigh whether a £44 million investment in McTominay addresses their long-term midfield needs or if the focus should shift to new talent. For more news and in-depth analysis, visit for more news.

Overall, the Scott McTominay transfer saga highlights the complexities of modern football’s transfer market—sometimes, letting go of a player can spark their best form elsewhere, leaving their former club to ponder what might have been.