Mary Earps Faces Backlash Over Lionesses Legacy and Criticism

Mary Earps, England’s former No.1 goalkeeper, finds her Lionesses legacy under scrutiny after a series of controversial remarks about her successor Hannah Hampton and manager Sarina Wiegman. Just months ago, Earps stood as a national hero, her performances key in England’s European Championship triumph and their run to the 2023 Women’s World Cup final. Now, as she prepares to return to Manchester United with Paris Saint-Germain in the Women’s Champions League, her reputation faces an unexpected test.

Mary Earps: From Lionesses Icon to Controversy

Mary Earps’ transition from celebrated shot-stopper to a figure of debate began with her recently published book, ‘All In.’ In its pages, Earps revisits her demotion from England’s starting lineup and openly criticizes both Hannah Hampton and Sarina Wiegman. Earps claims that “bad behaviour” was “rewarded” when Hampton was reinstated after initially being dropped due to attitude issues, despite Wiegman stating Hampton had resolved her personal concerns.

The Rise of Hannah Hampton

Hannah Hampton’s ascent to England’s first-choice goalkeeper before Euro 2025 reshaped the Lionesses’ pecking order. Despite being sidelined at age 21, Hampton’s professionalism impressed not only Wiegman but also Chelsea managers Emma Hayes and Sonia Bompastor, who now publicly support her. As Bompastor put it: “Hannah is class—she’s professional and a good person. I want to show my support for her in this situation.”

Contrasting Perspectives Fuel the Debate

While Hampton has spoken positively about Earps and acknowledges her influence—especially when the two received the Women’s Yashin Trophy together—Earps’ critical tone in her book has drawn ire from fans and coaching staff alike. The internet has been quick to rally behind Hampton and Wiegman, seeing Earps’ comments as poorly timed and unnecessarily harsh.

Mary Earps’ Lionesses Legacy Under the Microscope

The fallout from Earps’ international retirement has intensified the debate. Her decision—made just before the Euros after learning she would be second choice—left England with only one capped goalkeeper. Although Earps stated, “I’d rather Khiara Keating get the experience,” many viewed the move as self-serving, especially given Keating’s inexperience at 21 years old.

Criticism of Sarina Wiegman

Earps’ remarks about Sarina Wiegman, the manager who revived her international career, have been particularly jarring. Despite Wiegman’s trust and support, Earps described the announcement of her demotion as “bullsh*t,” prompting Bompastor and others to demand respect for both Hampton and Wiegman, who has led teams to multiple European titles.

Public Reaction and Social Media Sentiment

With Earps set for a highly anticipated return to Old Trafford, social media channels have been flooded with disappointment from fans. Many believe Earps’ legacy, once worthy of celebration, is now irrevocably tarnished by her comments and actions.

What’s Next for Mary Earps and the Lionesses?

As the Football Association plans a tribute for Earps, questions remain about how she will be received. Her contributions to Manchester United’s women’s team and the England squad are undeniable. However, the impact of her words has triggered a reevaluation of her place in English football history.

For more news on women’s football and the latest developments, visit our homepage for more news.

Opinion: Time to Heal and Move Forward

The Mary Earps saga is a reminder of how quickly fortunes can change in football. While her achievements should not be forgotten, navigating transitions with grace is vital for any legacy. Earps’ story now serves as both a cautionary tale and a call for greater unity within the Lionesses squad. As the team prepares for future tournaments, mutual respect and positive leadership will be crucial in shaping the next chapter of English women’s football.