Messi vs Ronaldo: Garay Ranks Messi Above Ronaldo in GOAT Debate

Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo is a debate that continues to divide football fans and experts alike, but former Real Madrid and Argentina defender Ezequiel Garay has added a unique perspective to the discussion. Having shared the pitch with both superstars, Garay’s verdict is clear—Messi stands above Ronaldo as the greatest of all time.

Garay’s Unique Experience with Messi and Ronaldo

Ezequiel Garay is among the rare group of players who have played alongside both Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo at the highest level. Garay spent three seasons at Real Madrid, from 2008 to 2011, during Ronaldo’s early years at the club as he began his historic journey towards becoming Real Madrid’s all-time leading scorer. Additionally, Garay earned 32 caps for Argentina, contributing to a national team that included Messi and other stars like Sergio Agüero.

Garay’s GOAT Verdict: Lionel Messi Above Cristiano Ronaldo

When asked to weigh in on the GOAT (Greatest of All Time) debate, Garay did not hesitate to name Lionel Messi as his number one, with Cristiano Ronaldo following as number two. “They are two very different players, but the one who has surprised me the most is Leo. I have been fortunate enough to play with both of them, but Leo is something else,” Garay told DAZN. He emphasized Messi’s extraordinary natural talent and vision, stating that in “pure football terms,” Messi is unmatched.

While Garay acknowledged Ronaldo’s incredible discipline and relentless work ethic, he insisted that Messi possesses an innate brilliance that sets him apart. According to Garay, Ronaldo’s achievements are the result of years of hard work and sacrifice, whereas Messi’s genius appears almost effortless.

Ronaldo’s Legendary Work Ethic: Tevez Story Confirmed

The tales of Ronaldo’s commitment and early-morning training sessions have become legendary in football circles. Carlos Tevez, another former teammate of both Ronaldo and Messi, once described how Ronaldo was always the first to arrive at training—even beating Tevez at his own game when he tried to arrive before the Portuguese star. Garay confirmed these stories, recalling that Ronaldo was often the first to arrive at 6 am and the last to leave, performing lengthy routines to ensure he was in peak condition.

“Tevez’s story is true,” Garay remarked. “Cristiano was always the first in and the last out at Real Madrid. His dedication is unmatched. From gym work to physiotherapy, he would do everything possible to maintain his level.”

Messi’s Natural Genius vs Ronaldo’s Relentless Drive

Garay’s views echo those of Tevez, who also described Messi as a player blessed with God-given talent, while Ronaldo’s success is grounded in his work ethic. Tevez once famously said, “Cristiano had to work and prepare himself to be the best; it comes naturally for Leo.” Messi’s footballing instincts, flair, and technical ability make him a once-in-a-generation talent, whereas Ronaldo’s journey is a testament to the power of determination and self-improvement.

Messi and Ronaldo: Still Going Strong

Despite being in the twilight years of their careers, both Messi and Ronaldo continue to perform at the highest level. Ronaldo remains under contract with Al-Nassr in the Saudi Pro League until 2027, while Messi is a key figure at MLS Cup winners Inter Miami, with his contract running through 2028. Both are expected to represent their respective national teams—Portugal and Argentina—at the upcoming World Cup, maintaining their legendary status in world football.

Speculation persists about a potential reunion in Major League Soccer, with rumors swirling about Ronaldo’s future following reports of unrest in Saudi Arabia. While fans dream of seeing these two icons share a pitch once more, both continue to carve their own paths, chasing new milestones.

Opinion: Why Garay’s Messi vs Ronaldo Verdict Resonates

Garay’s perspective carries weight because of his rare experience playing alongside both Messi and Ronaldo. His insights highlight the distinct ways greatness manifests in football—through Messi’s innate magic and Ronaldo’s tireless pursuit of excellence. While the debate may never be fully settled, Garay’s verdict underscores the value of natural talent and the awe it inspires in those lucky enough to witness it firsthand.

For more news and in-depth football analysis, visit for more news.