Newcastle Player Ratings: Aubameyang Punishes Magpies’ Error

Newcastle player ratings are under scrutiny after a costly blunder from Nick Pope allowed Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang to turn the tide in Marseille’s favor, sending the Magpies to a 2-1 Champions League defeat. This loss leaves Eddie Howe’s side facing a tougher road to the knockout stage, with little margin for further mistakes.

Newcastle Player Ratings: First-Half Promise Ends in Disappointment

Newcastle player ratings started strong as the Magpies came out aggressive at the Orange Velodrome. In-form Harvey Barnes gave Newcastle an early lead in the sixth minute, coolly finishing after a clever assist from Sandro Tonali. Malick Thiaw nearly doubled the advantage moments later, only to see his header cleared off the line by Marseille’s Pierre-Emile Hojbjerg.

Despite this bright opening, the remainder of the first half saw Marseille slowly seize control. Nick Pope was forced into action several times, making key saves to preserve the lead as Roberto De Zerbi’s side pressed relentlessly. Newcastle’s backline began to feel the pressure, and the cracks showed after the break.

Aubameyang’s Quick Double Stuns Newcastle

The game’s momentum shifted dramatically at the start of the second half. Newcastle’s hopes unraveled when Nick Pope, looking to clear danger, rushed far outside his box and was beaten by Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang. The former Arsenal striker poked the ball past Pope before finishing from a tight angle, capitalizing on the goalkeeper’s error. Moments later, Aubameyang struck again—this time directing Timothy Weah’s precise cross into the net, sending the French fans into celebration and leaving Newcastle stunned.

Marseille’s double was a harsh lesson for the visitors, who now must regroup ahead of tougher fixtures in their Champions League group against Bayer Leverkusen, PSV, and Paris Saint-Germain.

Individual Newcastle Player Ratings

Goalkeeper & Defence

Nick Pope (4/10): Began well with two impressive stops but his critical second-half error shifted the match. His decision-making cost Newcastle dearly.
Tino Livramento (6/10): Active defensively, dealt with Weah’s overlapping runs but struggled as the match wore on.
Malick Thiaw (7/10): Nearly opened the scoring and showed resilience in defense, making several key clearances.
Fabian Schar (6/10): Commanding presence, but eventually overwhelmed by Marseille’s pressure. Subbed on the hour mark.
Dan Burn (6/10): Returned to the starting XI and worked hard to stifle Marseille’s attack; maintained composure despite the onslaught.

Midfield

Bruno Guimaraes (7/10): Tireless performance. Played mostly in his own half, displaying defensive grit and energy.
Sandro Tonali (6/10): Provided the assist for Barnes’s goal but missed a golden opportunity to extend the lead before halftime.
Joe Willock (5/10): Picked up an early yellow and struggled to impact the game positively. Subbed in the 72nd minute.

Attack

Jacob Murphy (6/10): Lively in the opening stages but faded as Marseille gained control. Taken off after 60 minutes.
Anthony Gordon (6/10): Reinstated to the start but had a subdued evening, unable to contribute decisively in attack.
Harvey Barnes (7/10): Scored early, continuing his rich vein of form. Remained Newcastle’s brightest attacking spark.

Substitutes & Manager

Lewis Miley (6/10): Effective in a defensive role, made important blocks.
Anthony Elanga (6/10): Energetic cameo, but lacked time to make a significant impact.
Lewis Hall (5/10): Showed intent going forward but had little influence.
Jacob Ramsey (6/10): Injected dynamism in midfield, showing promise in limited minutes.
Nick Woltemade (5/10): Introduced late, with limited involvement.
Eddie Howe (5/10): Early tactical switch looked promising, but team errors proved costly and substitutions failed to turn the tide.

Marseille’s Historic Win and What’s Next for Newcastle

This result marks Marseille’s first victory over English opposition in 12 attempts, a significant psychological boost for the Ligue 1 side. For Newcastle, the defeat is a sobering setback, intensifying the pressure ahead of pivotal fixtures in a fiercely competitive group.

Eddie Howe’s men must now show resilience and composure to stay in the Champions League hunt. The margin for error is gone, and any repeat of individual mistakes—like Pope’s misjudgment—could prove fatal to their European campaign.

Opinion: Newcastle Must Learn from Defensive Lapses

While Newcastle demonstrated attacking promise, especially early on, this defeat underscores the importance of concentration and decision-making at the highest level. Nick Pope’s error was a turning point, but the Magpies also failed to maintain their composure as Marseille pressed. As the group stage reaches its critical phase, Newcastle will need to rediscover their defensive solidity and mental toughness if they are to progress.

For more insights and updates on European football and Newcastle’s Champions League journey, visit for more news.