Phil Foden’s England Struggles: Can He Match His Man City Form?

Phil Foden’s England record continues to puzzle both fans and pundits. While the Manchester City star dazzles week in, week out at club level—amassing an impressive 104 goals and 64 assists in 333 City appearances—his contribution for the Three Lions tells a very different story. With just four goals in 45 caps, Foden’s international strike rate lags far behind his club form, raising the question: why does Phil Foden struggle to replicate his Manchester City heroics for England?

Phil Foden’s Frustrating England Output

Despite his incredible talent, Foden sits joint-140th on England’s all-time scorer list, alongside Nicky Barmby, and below even some notable defenders. This surprising statistic is a stark contrast to his elite club output. His last England goal came in a friendly against Scotland in September 2023, with his previous competitive goal dating back to the 2022 World Cup. Since the last World Cup, Foden has only provided one assist for England, further highlighting his diminished influence on the international stage.

Positional Issues and Tactical Dilemmas

Part of the problem may lie in how Foden is deployed. At Manchester City, he flourishes centrally, often with the freedom to drift and create. With England, however, he’s frequently stationed on the left or, at times, shoehorned into various roles to accommodate other stars like Jude Bellingham. During Euro 2024, Foden’s struggles in both wide and central positions—especially sharing the field with Bellingham—became a focal point of criticism, with fans and analysts questioning whether both can coexist effectively.

Managerial Challenges: Southgate and Tuchel

Former manager Gareth Southgate and now Thomas Tuchel have both wrestled with the challenge of integrating Foden without blunting England’s overall attack. Tuchel, openly acknowledging the need for team cohesion over individual brilliance, has alternated between benching and starting Foden. He stressed in recent interviews that star names alone do not make a team and has shown a willingness to rotate even high-profile talents if it benefits the collective.

Comparing Club and Country

At Manchester City, Foden is a key figure in Pep Guardiola’s fluid system, benefitting from consistent positioning and a tactical setup that maximizes his strengths. Conversely, England’s more rigid structures and the need to fit multiple high-profile players into a starting XI has often left Foden in less influential roles, limiting his ability to impact games in the same way.

Phil Foden and England: The Path Forward

Tuchel’s recent comments suggest a shift towards deploying Foden centrally, much like his City role, and potentially rotating him with Bellingham rather than trying to force both into the same positions. As England heads into crucial World Cup qualifiers, the focus will be on finding the right balance—leveraging the individual brilliance of players like Foden while maintaining the team unity that Tuchel values. The next few matches could be pivotal in determining whether Foden can finally translate his club form to the international stage.

Personal Factors and Team Dynamics

It’s important to acknowledge the personal challenges Foden has faced, including missing part of Euro 2024 for family reasons. Such off-field factors can affect performance and mindset, especially on the international stage where pressure is immense.

Can Phil Foden Deliver for England?

Ultimately, the responsibility falls on both Foden and his manager. With Tuchel’s pragmatic approach and a squad brimming with talent, Foden must prove he can be as decisive for England as he is for City. If he does, he could etch his name among England’s greats—not just as a club phenomenon but as a true international star.

For more news, visit for more news.

Opinion: Time for Foden to Take Center Stage

Phil Foden’s England journey has, so far, been a story of unfulfilled potential. But with managerial support and the right tactical system, his best days for the Three Lions could still be ahead. It’s time for both Foden and England to find a formula that allows his brilliance to shine on the biggest stage.