Premier League’s Most Disappointing Signings of 2025-26

Premier League signings have once again made headlines during the 2025-26 campaign, as clubs splurged over £3 billion in a record-breaking transfer window. Despite these astronomical fees and the anticipation they generated, several high-profile arrivals have failed to meet expectations in England’s top flight, leaving fans and managers alike frustrated.

Big Money, Low Returns: The Struggles of Star Arrivals

Liverpool led the spending spree with over £415 million invested in new talent after their title-winning season under Arne Slot. Clubs like Manchester City, Chelsea, Manchester United, Newcastle, Nottingham Forest, and Tottenham also dipped deep into their coffers. However, for every Rayan Cherki or Bryan Mbeumo who hit the ground running, there have been marquee signings who have yet to justify their hefty price tags.

Premier League Signings Underwhelm: Isak, Gyokeres, Gittens and More

Alexander Isak’s £125m move to Liverpool was expected to guarantee goals. Yet, the Swedish striker has managed just three goals in 16 appearances and has been sidelined by injury, unable to replicate his Newcastle form. Meanwhile, Viktor Gyokeres was brought in to spearhead Arsenal’s title charge after a prolific spell at Sporting CP. The transition has been tough, with the forward netting only five times in 17 league matches and struggling to adapt to Mikel Arteta’s system.

Chelsea’s £52m winger Jamie Gittens, who dazzled at Borussia Dortmund, has found Premier League life challenging. Despite his raw potential, he’s been outshone by Alejandro Garnacho and failed to make a consistent impact, registering only two assists in 16 games.

Further Flops: From Sancho to Elanga

Jadon Sancho, on loan at Aston Villa, has yet to register a goal or assist in 15 outings, raising further questions about his future at the top level. Milos Kerkez was expected to fill Andrew Robertson’s boots at Liverpool, but the former Bournemouth left-back has struggled with defensive lapses and tactical discipline.

Newcastle’s third-most expensive signing, Anthony Elanga, was tipped to build on a stellar season with Nottingham Forest but is still searching for his first goal after 25 games. Nottingham Forest’s Arnaud Kalimuendo and Everton’s Thierno Barry have also struggled, unable to establish themselves despite solid reputations from previous leagues.

Loan Moves Gone Wrong: Elliott and Sancho’s Dilemmas

Harvey Elliott’s move to Aston Villa has backfired, with the midfielder barely featuring due to selection issues and FIFA regulations limiting his ability to transfer again this season. Sancho’s loan at Villa has seen more of the same, with little to show for his significant wages.

Premier League Signings: Injury Woes and Adjustment Struggles

Manchester United’s £74m striker Benjamin Sesko, signed for his potential, has yet to deliver, hampered by injuries and inexperience at this level. Everton’s Thierno Barry, full of promise and ambition, has struggled for composure in front of goal, contributing to his team’s lacklustre attack.

What’s Gone Wrong for These Premier League Signings?

The reasons behind these disappointing Premier League signings are varied. Injuries, tactical mismatches, pressure from hefty price tags, and the sheer physical and mental demands of adapting to English football have all played a part. Some, like Isak and Kerkez, have seen their integration hindered by lack of pre-season or immediate pressure to perform. Others, such as Gittens and Elanga, have found it difficult to impose themselves amid fierce competition for places.

Room for Redemption?

There is still time for these players to turn their fortunes around as the season progresses. Whether they can silence their critics depends on their resilience, adaptability, and, in some cases, sheer luck in avoiding further injuries. With the January transfer window looming, clubs may look for quick fixes, but many of these signings will be determined to prove their worth in the Premier League.

For more insight and coverage from the world of football, visit for more news.

Opinion: Lessons from a Costly Window

The 2025-26 season serves as a reminder that Premier League signings, no matter how promising on paper, are always a gamble. Clubs might be better served balancing mega-money moves with careful squad planning and patience for adaptation. With so much talent still searching for form, the second half of the season will be pivotal in defining whether these high-profile transfers go down as flops or late bloomers.