Real Madrid Player Ratings: Defensive Collapse in Atletico Thrashing

Real Madrid player ratings suffered a major hit after a disastrous display against Atletico Madrid in the city derby, as Los Blancos endured a humbling 5-2 defeat that raised major concerns over their defensive stability and Champions League prospects.

Chaos at the Metropolitano: Real Madrid Player Ratings Explained

The much-anticipated Madrid derby at the Metropolitano quickly turned into a nightmare for Real Madrid’s back line. Atletico Madrid were relentless from the opening whistle, capitalizing on every defensive lapse. Robin Le Normand set the tone with a well-taken header, exposing Los Blancos’ vulnerability in aerial duels. Despite Kylian Mbappe equalizing with a sharp finish after a clever pass from Arda Guler, Real Madrid’s defensive woes only deepened.

Guler, showing moments of brilliance, soon put Madrid ahead with a composed finish, but the visiting defense could not withstand Atletico’s direct attacks. Alex Sorloth capitalized on more poor marking to equalize before the break, heading past Thibaut Courtois, who was repeatedly left exposed.

Second Half: Real Madrid’s Defensive Frailties Exposed

After halftime, Real Madrid’s defensive structure unraveled completely. A high boot from Guler gifted Atletico a penalty, which Julian Alvarez dispatched confidently to restore the home side’s lead. Alvarez struck again shortly after the hour mark, this time curling a superb free-kick into the net. The Real Madrid player ratings reflect a night to forget for defenders Dean Huijsen and Eder Militao, both struggling to contain Atletico’s aggressive front line and quick transitions.

Antoine Griezmann capped off Atletico’s dominance in stoppage time, gliding a shot into the bottom corner to seal a famous victory. The 5-2 scoreline was a fair reflection of Atletico’s superiority and Real Madrid’s defensive disarray.

Forwards Shine but Real Madrid’s Defense Falters

Despite glimpses of attacking quality from Mbappe and Guler, the defensive failings overshadowed Madrid’s offensive efforts. Mbappe’s well-taken goal and Guler’s fine finish were the only highlights in an otherwise disappointing evening. Vinicius Jr. and Rodrygo worked hard to create openings, but Los Blancos’ inability to keep Atletico at bay proved decisive.

Dean Huijsen and Eder Militao struggled with positioning and were frequently caught out by the pace and movement of Atletico’s front line. Dani Carvajal and Ferland Mendy were similarly overrun on the flanks, as Madrid failed to cope with Atletico’s wide overloads and rapid attacks down the wings.

Midfield Battle: Atletico Outmuscle Los Blancos

In midfield, Real Madrid’s usual control deserted them. Toni Kroos and Eduardo Camavinga were unable to disrupt Atletico’s rhythm or shield their defense. Atletico pressed relentlessly, forcing errors and capitalizing on turnovers. The lack of protection left the defense increasingly vulnerable, which the home side exploited ruthlessly.

Julian Alvarez Outshines Kylian Mbappe in the Madrid Derby

While Kylian Mbappe found the net, it was Julian Alvarez who truly stole the show. The Argentine forward was a constant menace, notching two crucial goals and creating headaches for Madrid’s back line with his movement and pressing. His performance underlined Atletico’s attacking threat and highlighted the gap in Real Madrid’s current defensive setup.

Real Madrid Player Ratings vs. Atletico Madrid

– Thibaut Courtois: 5/10 – Left exposed too often, made a few decent saves.
– Dani Carvajal: 4/10 – Overrun on his side, struggled defensively.
– Eder Militao: 3/10 – Caught out for multiple goals, lacked composure.
– Dean Huijsen: 3/10 – Defensive errors led to goals, poor positioning.
– Ferland Mendy: 4/10 – Failed to contain Atletico’s wingers.
– Toni Kroos: 5/10 – Couldn’t dictate the tempo, overrun in midfield.
– Eduardo Camavinga: 5/10 – Lost midfield battle, struggled physically.
– Vinicius Jr.: 6/10 – Provided attacking impetus, limited impact.
– Arda Guler: 7/10 – Scored, assisted, but gave away a costly penalty.
– Rodrygo: 6/10 – Tireless effort, but lacked end product.
– Kylian Mbappe: 7/10 – Scored Madrid’s opener, but outshone by Alvarez.

Champions League Implications and Looking Ahead

This heavy defeat raises significant questions about Real Madrid’s readiness for upcoming Champions League challenges. The flaws in defense must be addressed urgently if Los Blancos are to compete for silverware this season. The likes of Dean Huijsen and Eder Militao will need to regroup and find stability, while the midfield must offer better support.

For more news on Real Madrid’s performances and Champions League updates, visit for more news.

Opinion: Defensive Overhaul Needed for Real Madrid

In my view, Real Madrid’s attacking talent is undeniable, but this derby defeat starkly exposed the defensive shortcomings that could derail their ambitions. Manager Carlo Ancelotti must prioritize defensive organization and perhaps consider rotating his options at the back. Without swift improvements, more tough nights could be on the horizon.