Ruben Amorim Faces Scrutiny After Manchester Derby Defeat

Ruben Amorim’s future at Manchester United hangs in the balance after a heavy 3-0 defeat at the hands of Manchester City. As doubts continue to swirl around the Portuguese coach, City’s resounding win only fueled the debate about United’s direction under Amorim’s leadership.

Ruben Amorim Under Pressure After City Loss

Ruben Amorim’s tenure as Manchester United manager suffered another major blow after their latest defeat in the Manchester derby. From the opening moments, United tried to impose themselves but faltered as Phil Foden broke the deadlock, sending City on their way to a dominant victory. The atmosphere in the Etihad Stadium quickly turned from tense to mocking as City fans sang songs originally intended to praise Amorim, using United’s own chants to taunt their rivals.

Amorim’s early promise at United is now overshadowed by tactical rigidity and an apparent refusal to adapt. His unwavering commitment to his system—despite mounting losses—raises questions about whether he is the right man to steer United back to former glories.

Manchester City’s Dominance Exposes United’s Flaws

City’s clinical performance not only highlighted their own resurgence, with Erling Haaland looking back to his sharpest, but also amplified United’s shortcomings. The second half showcased a gulf in quality, with United rarely threatening and City easily controlling proceedings.

The defeat marks United’s worst start to a league season since 1992-93, a campaign that ironically ended with their first-ever Premier League title. However, few believe history will repeat itself under Amorim, given his reluctance to change both tactics and philosophy.

Amorim’s Stubbornness: A Double-Edged Sword

“I am going to play my way until I want to change,” Amorim declared after the match. While his conviction is admirable on some levels, results are testing the patience of both fans and club executives. Sir Jim Ratcliffe and United’s hierarchy now face a critical choice: stick with Amorim’s vision or seek new leadership before the season slips away.

Winners and Losers of the Derby

While Erling Haaland and Phil Foden shone for City, the derby was full of losers in United red. City fans enjoyed their moment of schadenfreude, repurposing Amorim’s songs for their own amusement—symbolizing a role reversal between the two Manchester giants.

What’s Next for Ruben Amorim and United?

As pressure intensifies, Amorim’s insistence on his methods suggests a turbulent road ahead. The question for United’s board is not just about loyalty to a manager’s philosophy, but whether that philosophy is yielding results. The Premier League has evolved rapidly since United’s last era of dominance, and adaptability has become a necessity for success.

If Amorim cannot deliver a turnaround soon, it’s likely only a matter of time before United’s leadership decides a change is necessary—regardless of his unwavering self-belief.

Opinion: Change Needed Before It’s Too Late

While Ruben Amorim’s principles are commendable, elite football requires flexibility and results. United’s history is built on adaptation and relentless pursuit of excellence. Right now, the evidence suggests a leadership change may be the only way to halt the slide and restore hope to the Old Trafford faithful.

For more news and in-depth analysis on football’s biggest stories, visit for more news.