Shearer Criticizes Man Utd Over Benjamin Sesko Transfer Fee

Manchester United’s Benjamin Sesko transfer has drawn sharp criticism from Alan Shearer, who believes the Red Devils overpaid and questions the striker’s impact after a rocky start at Old Trafford.

Benjamin Sesko Transfer Under Scrutiny

Benjamin Sesko’s move to Manchester United from RB Leipzig was among the most talked-about transfers of the summer. United, desperate to address their attacking shortcomings after a lackluster 2024-25 season, committed a hefty £74 million ($100 million) for the highly-rated Slovenian striker. However, the early returns have been underwhelming, with Sesko scoring just two goals in 12 appearances across all competitions, including the Premier League.

Alan Shearer’s Candid Assessment

Newcastle United legend Alan Shearer was quick to share his doubts about the wisdom behind Manchester United’s investment in Benjamin Sesko. Speaking to Betfair, Shearer remarked, “One player that must do better for United is Benjamin Sesko. They paid 70-odd million for him. That was a lot of money. I know it’s the market, but it was too much. He’s had a tough start and I don’t expect huge things from him to be honest. I think he’s a good player, but I’m not sure he’s any more than that. He should have scored a couple more goals than he has so far, especially considering the money United paid.”

Slow Start and Injury Concerns

Sesko’s adaptation to the Premier League has not been helped by injury setbacks. In a recent 2-2 draw against Tottenham Hotspur, manager Ruben Amorim brought Sesko on in the 58th minute, only to substitute him late after a forceful challenge by Micky van de Ven. Amorim expressed his concerns post-match, stating, “That is not the biggest concern now. That happens, especially with a striker. I am more concerned with an injury, because it’s in the knee, we don’t know, we need Ben to be a better team.” Tests have since suggested Sesko avoided serious injury, but questions remain about his readiness for upcoming matches.

Manchester United’s Risky Gamble on Sesko

Manchester United’s hefty investment in Benjamin Sesko was seen as a bold move to fix their chronic scoring issues. Despite starting in only six of United’s 11 league matches, Sesko’s lack of form and fitness has drawn significant attention. The pressure on the club to justify the record fee is mounting with every goalless performance.

International Fallout: Slovenia’s Response

The handling of Sesko’s injury has also caused friction between Manchester United and the Slovenian national team. Slovenia head coach Matjaz Kek openly criticized United for failing to communicate about Sesko’s condition, stating, “With all due respect to a great club like Manchester United, we have officially not received anything yet; no papers, no documents. We want our medical team to also take a look at it. The only thing that matters to me is his wellbeing.” Kek also emphasized the importance of respect towards the Slovenian national team, especially with World Cup qualifiers on the horizon.

When Will Sesko Return?

United fans are now eager to see if Sesko will regain fitness in time for the upcoming fixture against Everton on November 24. The club is optimistic about a swift recovery, but manager Amorim’s selection will hinge on the striker’s condition post-international break.

Opinion: Patience or Panic for Manchester United?

Manchester United’s calculated risk in signing Benjamin Sesko is beginning to look questionable, especially given the scrutiny around his price tag and early struggles. While Sesko’s talent is undeniable, the Premier League’s intensity and the weight of expectation seem to be affecting his adaptation. Injuries have further complicated his progress, but it’s premature to write him off entirely. If given time, support, and a clear run in the starting eleven, Sesko could yet prove his worth. For United, patience may be the key to seeing a return on their substantial investment. As always, for more news and updates on football’s biggest stories, visit for more news.