Should Man Utd Re-Hire Ole Gunnar Solskjaer as Manager?

Manchester United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer continues to be at the center of debate as the club faces mounting pressure after a turbulent start to the season. With Ruben Amorim struggling and reportedly having just three games left to save his job, discussions about re-hiring Solskjaer have intensified. The question remains: can bringing back a former coach like Solskjaer truly revive Manchester United’s fortunes?

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s Previous Tenure at Manchester United

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s appointment as Manchester United manager in 2018 brought renewed optimism to Old Trafford. The legendary former striker initially impressed by restoring the club’s famous counter-attacking style, reminiscent of the Sir Alex Ferguson era. Under Solskjaer, United finished second in the Premier League in the 2020-21 season and reached the UEFA Europa League final. His tenure was marked by a positive atmosphere and a belief in youth development—but was also hampered by inconsistency and a failure to win major silverware.

Should Manchester United Re-Hire Ole Gunnar Solskjaer?

The idea of re-hiring Ole Gunnar Solskjaer is not without precedent in football. Clubs often turn to familiar faces in times of crisis, hoping that a return to a successful past can yield positive results. Yet, bringing back a former manager is a gamble which has produced mixed outcomes across football history.

The Trend of Managers Returning to Former Clubs

Several high-profile managers have returned to their old clubs, with varying degrees of success. Jose Mourinho famously re-joined Chelsea in 2013, leading them to another Premier League title. Meanwhile, Zinedine Zidane’s return to Real Madrid resulted in more Champions League glory. However, not all returns work out; Kenny Dalglish’s second spell at Liverpool and Fabio Capello’s return to AC Milan were far less fruitful.

Lessons From the Past: When Managerial Returns Work

A successful managerial return often depends on several factors: timing, squad quality, boardroom stability, and the manager’s willingness to adapt. Mourinho’s return to Chelsea was boosted by significant financial backing and a strong squad, while Zidane walked back into a Real Madrid team still filled with world-class talent. The returning manager must also demonstrate tactical evolution—simply repeating the approach that worked before may not be enough in a changing football landscape.

Does Ole Gunnar Solskjaer Fit the Bill for Manchester United?

Solskjaer’s deep understanding of Manchester United’s culture and history is undeniable. Players responded to his leadership, and his man-management helped repair a fractured dressing room. However, his previous spell exposed tactical limitations, especially against top opposition. The modern Premier League demands adaptability and a clear long-term vision—qualities that critics argue Solskjaer still needs to prove.

Challenges Facing Any Returning Manager at Old Trafford

Any manager returning to Manchester United will inherit significant challenges. The current squad, shaped by expensive signings and fluctuating form, lacks consistency and clear identity. The club’s structure remains in flux, with fan expectations at an all-time high. Without a clear plan and support from the board, even a club legend like Solskjaer would face an uphill battle.

Top 10 Managers Who Returned to Former Clubs

History provides ample case studies for Manchester United to consider before making a decision. Here are 10 notable managerial returns:

1. Jose Mourinho (Chelsea)
2. Zinedine Zidane (Real Madrid)
3. Kenny Dalglish (Liverpool)
4. Fabio Capello (AC Milan, Real Madrid)
5. Jupp Heynckes (Bayern Munich)
6. Louis van Gaal (Barcelona)
7. Marcello Lippi (Juventus)
8. Guus Hiddink (Chelsea)
9. Frank Rijkaard (Sparta Rotterdam)
10. Claudio Ranieri (Valencia, Roma)

The experiences of these managers highlight the unpredictability of such decisions. Some enjoyed newfound success, while others failed to replicate their earlier triumphs.

Conclusion: Should United Look Back or Forward?

Re-hiring Ole Gunnar Solskjaer would offer Manchester United familiarity and a return to certain club values. However, the challenges of modern management mean sentiment alone cannot guarantee success. The club must weigh the allure of nostalgia against the need for progressive change and tactical innovation.

For more news and updates on Manchester United and global football, visit for more news.

Opinion: Is a Solskjaer Return the Right Move?

In my view, while Ole Gunnar Solskjaer brought stability and unity during his initial tenure, Manchester United’s ambitions require forward-thinking leadership and strategic vision. The club cannot afford to be driven by nostalgia; instead, it must seek a manager who can blend tradition with modern tactics to restore United to the pinnacle of English football.