Tony Meola Questions Joe Scally’s USMNT Absence

Joe Scally’s omission from USMNT friendlies raises eyebrows

Joe Scally, the talented right-back at Borussia Mönchengladbach, has unexpectedly been left out of Mauricio Pochettino’s squad for the USMNT’s October friendlies, sparking debate among fans and experts. Former U.S. goalkeeper Tony Meola is the latest to express his surprise, questioning whether Scally’s absence against Ecuador is truly about on-field performance or tactical considerations.

Joe Scally and the Mystery Behind His USMNT Omission

Scally’s progress in the Bundesliga has garnered consistently positive reviews. As a defensive stalwart for Mönchengladbach, many analysts expected his inclusion for the upcoming United States fixtures. Yet, his name was conspicuously missing when the squad was announced. Tony Meola, speaking to media, said, “Could it really come down to a golf cart ride?” That comment refers to rumors that non-football factors may have influenced Pochettino’s decision.

Tony Meola’s Perspective on Scally’s USMNT Future

Meola’s surprise is rooted in Scally’s recent performances and versatility, which have made him a strong contender for a USMNT spot. While Meola acknowledged the absence of midfielder Yunus Musah could be explained by tactical fit or form, he suggested Scally’s exclusion might be about more than just football. “With Scally, I feel there’s something else going on,” Meola added, noting that off-field dynamics can sometimes play an outsized role in national team selections.

Scally’s Strengths and the USMNT Right Back Debate

The USMNT has long sought reliable options at right-back, and Scally’s consistent performances in Germany have made him a favorite among supporters. His composure, defensive awareness, and ability to play higher up the pitch are qualities the national side often lacks. Leaving Scally out, especially when the team faces a robust Ecuador squad, has led to widespread speculation and frustration.

Possible Reasons for Exclusion: Beyond Form and Fitness

While coaches sometimes base their selections on tactical fit, form, or fitness, the discussion surrounding Scally’s omission has taken a different turn. Meola hinted that personal relationships or minor incidents—such as the now-infamous “golf cart ride” story—could have swayed Pochettino’s decision. Such non-sporting factors, though rare, are not unheard of in international football and have previously impacted squad harmony and choices.

Fans React to Scally’s Absence

USMNT supporters have been vocal online, questioning a decision that seems at odds with Scally’s club record. Many argue that leaving out one of the Bundesliga’s most consistent American defenders could hurt the team’s defensive stability. With key matches on the horizon, Scally’s experience and steady play may be missed.

Looking Ahead: What’s Next for Joe Scally and the USMNT?

The October friendlies provide a vital opportunity for Pochettino to assess his squad before major international competitions. If Scally’s absence is indeed due to off-field factors, it remains to be seen whether future line-ups will reflect a change in selection policies. For now, fans and pundits alike are left to wonder how long Scally’s exclusion will last and what it means for his international career.

For more news and insights on the USMNT and global football, visit for more news.

Opinion: A Missed Opportunity for USMNT Growth

Leaving Joe Scally out of the current squad appears to be a missed opportunity for the USMNT. His Bundesliga experience and recent form could have strengthened the team’s defensive options. If non-football reasons are at play, the coaching staff should reconsider their approach to ensure the best players represent the country. Transparency in selection is crucial for building trust among players and fans alike.